Decking materials · compared
Decking materials compared
“What material?” is usually the first question and rarely the most important one. The framing under the boards and the fixings holding them down are part of the material decision too. Here is how the common choices behave in Melbourne — and where we lean, and why.
How to read this
There is no single best board. The right choice depends on your budget, how much maintenance you will actually do, the look you want and where the deck sits. We build mostly in natural timber because, detailed properly, it lasts and ages well — but the notes below are meant to help you decide, not to talk you into one answer.
Merbau
The default hardwood for a lot of Melbourne decks — dense, durable and usually around around $560/m² as a broad installed guide.
- Strengths: hard, durable, widely available, sits at a sensible price point.
- Watch for: heavy tannin bleed when new — it will stain light paving, render and grout if it is not managed in the first few rains.
- Best when: you want a proven hardwood deck without stepping up to the premium species.
Spotted gum
An Australian hardwood that is tough and hard-wearing, with strong grain and colour variation. Broad guide pricing often lands around around $675/m².
- Strengths: very hard and durable, holds up to traffic and weather, and performs well in exposed areas when maintained.
- Watch for: hardness makes it less forgiving to work — pre-drilling and good fixings matter.
- Best when: you want a long-lived feature deck and are happy to maintain it.
Blackbutt
A clean, straight-grained Australian hardwood with a paler, more even tone than spotted gum. Broad guide pricing often lands around around $690/m².
- Strengths: durable, consistent appearance, a lighter and calmer look than merbau or spotted gum.
- Watch for: a premium board price, like the other quality hardwoods.
- Best when: you want a lighter, more uniform hardwood look and accept the higher board cost.
Treated pine — mostly a framing material
Treated pine earns its place as the subframe under almost every deck, and as a budget board where the brief calls for it.
- As framing: the standard, sensible choice for bearers and joists — provided it is treated to the right hazard level for in-ground vs above-ground use.
- As a deck board: the cheapest option, fine when detailed and maintained, but softer and shorter-lived than the hardwoods.
- Watch for: using the wrong treatment level in the wrong spot — that is a structural shortcut, not a saving.
Composite decking — the honest version
Composite has a real place, and it is worth understanding properly rather than dismissing or overselling. It is a board choice, not a structural one — it still sits on a timber subframe that has to be built right.
- Strengths: low maintenance, no oiling, stable colour, no splinters — genuinely good if you will not maintain timber.
- Trade-offs: different look, can get hot underfoot in full sun, and quality varies a lot between products.
- Around pools: Made By Mobbs does not recommend plasticised decking around pools.
- Reality check: composite boards do not rescue a bad frame. A composite deck on a poorly ventilated, under-built subframe still moves and still has problems below.
Fixings and framing are part of the “material” decision
It is easy to pick a board and forget that the fixings and frame are doing the real work. They belong in the material conversation.
- Fixing method (hidden vs face) and grade (stainless vs galvanised) change both the look and the lifespan — detailed in the timber decking cost guide.
- Joist size and spacing have to suit the board you choose; the wrong frame undoes a good board.
- Near pools and the coast, hardware grade is not optional — cheap fixings rust and stain.
Which choices suit Melbourne conditions
Melbourne throws wet winters, dry summers and big day-to-night swings at a deck. That favours durable timber, proper detailing and a frame that can dry out, which is why natural timber is generally preferred for properly detailed timber decks in Melbourne, especially hardwood decks built as part of a larger outdoor renovation.
- Hardwoods (merbau, spotted gum, blackbutt): cope well with Melbourne swings when detailed and maintained — our usual recommendation.
- Treated pine: a fair budget board and the right framing timber, as long as the treatment level matches the situation.
- Composite: a valid option for some low-maintenance briefs — but still hold it to the same standard of frame, ventilation and drainage.
- In every case: the deck lasts on the strength of the subframe, the airflow and the drainage, not the badge on the board.
Common deck mistakes
- Choosing the board and ignoring the frame — the subframe and fixings decide how long any material lasts.
- Treating composite as a fix for bad structure — it is a board choice, not a substitute for a properly built, ventilated frame.
- Using the wrong treated-pine hazard level — above-ground timber in the ground is a shortcut that shows up as rot.
- Forgetting merbau tannin — new merbau bleeds and will stain light paving and render if it is not managed early.
When it helps to bring in Made By Mobbs
Made By Mobbs Landscapes designs and builds outdoor spaces in Melbourne — paving, planting, structure and the decks that tie a backyard together.
A deck lasts when the parts you cannot see are right: footings that suit the ground, a subframe sized and spaced properly, airflow underneath, water that drains away rather than sitting on the frame, and fixings chosen for the timber. We lean toward natural timber and proper detailing because that is what holds up — composite has its place, but it does not fix a frame that was never built to last.
This page is a guide, not a quote. A firm price needs a look at your site — access, ground conditions, how high the deck sits, and how it meets the house, the garden and any pool.
Questions we hear on site
- What is the best decking material for a Melbourne home?
- For most homes, a durable Australian hardwood like spotted gum or blackbutt, or merbau on a tighter budget, detailed on a properly ventilated treated-pine frame. Composite is a sensible choice if you genuinely will not maintain timber. There is no single best — it depends on budget, maintenance and the look you want.
- Is composite decking better than timber?
- Not better, different. Composite is low-maintenance and stable but costs more upfront, looks more uniform and can get hot in full sun. Timber is warmer and ages naturally but needs re-coating. Both rely on a well-built, ventilated subframe — the board does not fix a bad frame.
- Does merbau really stain paving?
- Yes — new merbau bleeds tannin heavily in the first rains and will stain light-coloured paving, render and grout if it is not managed. It is worth planning for, especially where the deck meets stone or concrete.
- Can I use the same treated pine for framing and boards?
- The framing and the surface have different jobs and often different treatment levels. In-ground and ground-contact framing needs a higher hazard-level treatment than above-ground timber. Matching the treatment to the situation is a structural decision, not a place to save money.
Footings, subframe, airflow and drainage decide whether a deck still feels solid in ten years — they are not details you sort out after the boards are down.
Planning a deck in Melbourne?
Talk through structure, timber and detailing with a team that builds the deck as part of the whole backyard — not as a board count on top of a quick frame.
Speak with Made By Mobbs Landscapes